What is the nature of the understanding of the concept of "wave particle duality" among Advanced level Physics student?
Quantum theory is arguably the most successful physical theory that has ever been conceptualised, and yet Einstein once remarked that quantum theory reminded him om 'the system of delusions of an exceedignly intelligent paranoiac, conocted of incoherent elements of thought.' (In Arthur Fine, 1986)
A the heart of quantum theory lies the concept of 'wave-particle duality'. What are electrons really like? Are they like particles or waves? Are they like both particles /and/ waves? These questions illustrate the psychological difficulties with which students are confronted when trying to incorporate the concepts of quantum physics into their over-all conceptual framework.
Particularly over the last two decades there has been considerable research interest in the student's perceptions of phenomena in such areas as energy, motion, the particulate nature of matter, electricity, and light (Pfundt and Duit, 1994). This is the first study of A-level Physics students' understanding fo quantum physics in the UK.
Following a review of the research literature this study identifies students' conceptions of quantum phenomena, models and the status of theoretical entities. The relationships between these conceptions are investigated by developing a structured questionnaire and using multivariate analytical techniques (multidimensional scaling, factor analysis, and cluster analysist) to identify groupings of conceptions and relate these to underlying interpretable dimensions. Differences between first and second year groups are described. The implications of the research findings are discussed.
Really think thesis...
The only way to get hold of this thesis appears to be to order it from Oxford - either by borrowing microfilms or ordering printed copies. (And the printed copies consists of three volumes...)
The thesis mainly describes a quantitative analysis of students' quantum mechanics conceptions. This is obtained by a large set of questions (see Ireson articles for these) and factor analysis, cluster analysis and multidimensional scaling.
Sadly, Azam Mashhadi will not do any more research due to serious illness.
There is a printed copy of the thesis at the Physics Education Research Group at Uppsala University, Sweden.